USB, Thunderbolt and FireWire compared

Updated · CSD London, East Sheen

Connector standards are a mess of names that look similar and behave nothing alike. What follows is the practical version: how fast each one really is, which connector to look for, and the reason a fast drive often runs slowly for reasons that have nothing to do with the drive.

The speeds, in one table

Speeds are quoted in megabits and gigabits per second, not megabytes — divide by roughly 8 for the file-copy figure you actually see. These are maximums under ideal conditions; real transfers are always slower.

StandardMaximum speedWhere you will meet it
USB 1.112 MbpsObsolete — keyboards and mice only
USB 2.0480 MbpsStill everywhere; fine for a mouse, slow for a drive
USB 3.0 / 3.1 Gen 1 / 3.2 Gen 15 GbpsThe common "blue port" — about 10× USB 2.0
USB 3.1 Gen 2 / 3.2 Gen 210 GbpsLater machines, often USB-C
USB 3.2 Gen 2×220 GbpsUncommon, USB-C only
USB420–40 GbpsRecent laptops, USB-C connector
Thunderbolt 3 / 440 GbpsMacs and better Windows laptops, USB-C connector
Thunderbolt 580 Gbps (120 in one direction)Newest high-end machines
FireWire 400 / 800400 / 800 MbpsObsolete — old camcorders and audio gear

Why the naming is so confusing

Because the USB standards body kept renaming the same thing. What launched as USB 3.0 became USB 3.1 Gen 1, then USB 3.2 Gen 1 — the same 5 Gbps throughout, with three names. Manufacturers quote whichever sounds best. The only figure worth reading on a box is the speed in Gbps; the version number tells you very little.

The connector is not the speed

This trips up almost everyone. USB-C is a connector shape, not a speed — a USB-C port can be anything from slow USB 2.0 to Thunderbolt 5, and they look identical. On Thunderbolt ports there is usually a small lightning-bolt symbol beside the socket. A plain blue USB-A port normally means at least 5 Gbps; a black one usually means USB 2.0.

Why your fast drive is running slowly

A connection runs at the speed of its slowest part, and there are four of them. Any one will cap the lot.

  • The port on the computer — a USB 2.0 port makes a 10 Gbps drive run at 480 Mbps
  • The cable — many USB-C cables carry power and USB 2.0 data only, including most phone-charging cables
  • The drive itself — a mechanical hard drive cannot fill even a USB 3.0 connection, so a faster port changes nothing
  • The other end — copying between two slow drives is limited by both

What about FireWire?

FireWire is finished. Apple removed it years ago and no current machine has a port. It still matters for one reason: a lot of irreplaceable material — DV camcorder tapes, older audio interfaces, early external drives — is stranded behind FireWire connectors. Adapters exist, and Thunderbolt-to-FireWire chains can still read old drives. If you have data on a FireWire device and nothing to plug it into, it is worth getting it off while working hardware still exists.

Which should you actually buy?

For an external drive to back up documents and photos, USB 3.0 at 5 Gbps is ample and it is what almost everything supports. Pay for Thunderbolt or USB4 only if you are moving very large files routinely — video editing, or working directly off an external drive — or if you want one cable that carries data, power and a monitor at once. Otherwise the money is better spent on a bigger or better-built drive.

Common questions

Is USB-C the same as Thunderbolt?
No. USB-C is the shape of the connector; Thunderbolt is a standard that uses that shape. A USB-C port might run at USB 2.0 speeds or at Thunderbolt 5 speeds, and they look the same. Thunderbolt ports are usually marked with a small lightning-bolt symbol.
Why is my external drive so slow even though it is USB 3?
Something in the chain is slower. The computer’s port may be USB 2.0, the cable may carry only USB 2.0 data (very common with cables supplied for charging), or the drive inside may be a mechanical hard drive that cannot go faster regardless of the connection.
How much faster is USB 3 than USB 2?
About ten times: USB 2.0 tops out at 480 Mbps and USB 3.0 at 5 Gbps. In practice the difference on a large file copy is dramatic, provided the drive itself can keep up.
Can I still get data off a FireWire drive?
Usually, yes, but it is worth doing sooner rather than later — no current computer has a FireWire port and the working hardware is getting scarcer. CSD London can read older FireWire drives and copy the contents onto something current.

More guides