NAS drives and home servers
Updated · CSD London, East Sheen
A NAS — Network Attached Storage — is a small box of hard drives that plugs into your router rather than into a computer. Everyone on the network can reach it, and it stays on when the computers are off. It is the most useful piece of kit most households and small offices have never considered, and it comes with one serious misconception.
What people actually use one for
A NAS is a general-purpose store rather than a single-purpose gadget.
- Automatic backups from every computer in the house, without plugging anything in
- One shared place for documents, so a small office is not emailing files to itself
- Photo and video libraries that have outgrown a laptop
- Streaming films and music to a television or phone
- Somewhere for security camera footage to record to
- Reaching your own files from outside the house, if set up carefully
The mistake that matters: RAID is not a backup
Most NAS boxes hold two or more drives and can mirror data across them, so that if one drive dies the data survives. That is RAID, and it protects against exactly one thing: a drive failing. It does not protect you from deleting a file by accident, from ransomware encrypting everything on the network, from theft, from fire, or from the NAS itself failing and taking both drives with it. All of those copy instantly to the mirror. A NAS is a superb place to keep a backup; a NAS on its own is not a backup.
The rule worth following instead
Three copies of anything you cannot bear to lose, on two different kinds of storage, with one of them somewhere else. In practice: the working copy on your computer, a copy on the NAS, and a third in cloud storage or on an external drive kept at another address. The third copy is the one that survives a burglary or a flood, and it is the one people skip.
NAS or cloud?
They solve overlapping problems differently. Cloud storage is off-site by definition, needs no maintenance, and costs a monthly fee that never stops — and restoring a very large amount of data over a domestic connection takes a long time. A NAS is a one-off purchase, is fast on your own network, and keeps your data on your premises, but it is yours to look after and it is in the same building as everything else. For most people the answer is both: a NAS for speed and capacity, cloud for the off-site copy.
If you already have one, two things to check
A NAS quietly doing nothing is worse than no NAS, because it creates false confidence.
- Confirm the backups are actually running, and try restoring a file — an untested backup is only a hope
- Check the drive health warnings; a NAS will usually tell you a drive is failing, if anyone is reading the notifications
- Keep its software updated. NAS boxes exposed to the internet have been a favourite ransomware target
- If it is reachable from outside, make sure that was a deliberate decision and is properly secured
Common questions
- What is a NAS drive?
- Network Attached Storage: a small box containing one or more hard drives that connects to your router rather than to a computer. Everyone on the network can use it, and it stays available when the computers are switched off — which makes it useful for automatic backups, shared files and media.
- Is a NAS a backup?
- Not on its own. Most NAS boxes mirror data across drives, which protects against a drive failing but nothing else. Accidental deletion, ransomware, theft and fire all affect the mirrored copy too. A NAS is an excellent place to keep a backup, alongside a second copy somewhere off the premises.
- NAS or cloud storage — which is better?
- They suit different needs. Cloud is off-site and needs no upkeep but costs a recurring fee and is slow to restore in bulk. A NAS is a one-off cost, fast on your own network and keeps data on your premises, but it sits in the same building as everything else. Most people are best served by both.
- Can data be recovered from a failed NAS?
- Often, yes, but it is more involved than a single drive because the data is spread across several disks in a specific arrangement. Do not reformat, reorder or rebuild the array — that frequently destroys what is still recoverable. CSD London handles NAS and RAID recovery at its East Sheen workshop.